After a rapid rise in billing errors and customer complaints related to billing and customer service, the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission (PUC) will meet this Thursday to consider whether an independent audit is needed.
The state Attorney General’s Office, Department of Commerce, City of St. Paul, Citizens Utility Board, Legal Services Advocacy Project, and solar industry groups jointly called for such an audit in an October 26 letter.
The Cities of St. Louis Park, Northfield, and Roseville have also called for a third-party audit based on billing-related issues with their municipal electric service, and the City of Minneapolis similarly filed a letter with the PUC describing significant billing errors. The Building Owners and Managers Association of Greater Minneapolis, too, has recommended an audit due to billing errors affecting their members, commercial real estate interests. The PUC has received more than 60 public comments, many of which detail significant and persistent billing issues or other concerns related to Xcel’s customer service. Such comments have been submitted by school districts, local businesses, and dozens of residential customers.
“We are seeing what appear to be systemic issues with Xcel’s billing and customer service, and the result is significant harm to customers,” said Annie Levenson-Falk, executive director of the Citizens Utility Board of Minnesota. “While Xcel has taken some actions to address these concerns, the issues continue to persist. It’s time for an external audit to identify the root causes of these problems and begin to resolve them.”
Evidence indicates:
• Pervasive billing issues, including incorrect bills; misapplied payments; inconsistent, missing, or delayed billing, and an inability on the part of Xcel representatives to correct errors. Multiple commenters report simply giving up, though they believe Xcel owes them hundreds or even thousands of dollars.
• Solar program errors, including incorrect or missing credits for customers’ solar energy production.
• Customer service agents refusing to set up affordable payment plans for past-due bills, contrary to state law and Xcel’s own policy. (The PUC Customer Affairs Office recently published a transcript of a customer service call evidencing this concern.)
• Incorrect information about rate and program options, and an inability to enroll the rate of a customer’s choosing.
• Xcel representatives fail to provide referrals to Energy Assistance or utility-run affordability programs for qualified customers calling regarding unaffordable bills.
“The City of Saint Paul is advocating to the Minnesota PUC to apply a third-party billing audit of their systems, specifically utilizing the City's own experience with misapplication of payments, resulting in late fees and facility disconnection threats for bills the City has paid," said Nick Stumo-Langer, Assistant Mayor for Housing, Economic Vibrancy, and Infrastructure for the City of St. Paul. "City staff have had to contacted Xcel hundreds of times over the past two years to resolve billing problems and other issues. We are laser-focused on energy affordability for our residents, and sharing our real experiences with our utility is an important way we are standing up for our residents."
The recommendation before the PUC on Thursday would permit the Department of Commerce to issue an RFP, select a qualified auditor, and supervise the audit. The audit would be paid for by Xcel, which would be prohibited from recouping the cost from ratepayers. The final audit report would be filed publicly with as little redaction as possible.
Examples of Xcel customers’ stories can be found on CUB’s website. The full record of public comments filed in this matter can be found on the State of Minnesota’s eDockets website (Docket Nos. 25-341 and 12-383).
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here