Dear Members of the Board, MPS staff, and Council Member Chowdhury,
I am writing to express my concerns about the proposed plans for building on the Cooper School site. I believe neighbors need and deserve more information and more consideration before this project moves forward.
First, I want to be clear that I am very happy about the general proposal that the Cooper School site be used once again as an educational space and I support and welcome Anishinabe Academy in particular. Like many of my other neighbors, I am enthusiastic about the Academy as a place contributing to cultural revitalization for urban indigenous youth. However, I am asking the Board not to advance the project further without additional public review of the site plan. Transparency and public input are important; our schools and neighborhoods are the most effective when we work together as partners to advance a shared vision. Partnership built on a solid foundation requires that we hear each other out, and work together to address trade-offs and issues of concern so we can move forward, united in purpose.
The size, scope and character of the proposed builds came as a surprise to many in the neighborhood. The proposed builds will far outstrip the current Cooper School footprint, taking up the entire block. Also, the proposed number of students in the largest plan (700) will be far more than the 200 students enrolled at the current Anishinabe Academy. These are significant differences from what many of us were expecting.
The recently published building proposals have newly raised the following site-impact questions that deserve to be answered and addressed:
- Green space
- How much green space access will be lost overall? The proposals account for lost area, but don’t indicate anything about lost access to space that remains.
- How will the remaining open space be configured so that undesirable effects of new construction are minimized for neighbors?
- Will neighbors and community members retain meaningful access to green space outside school hours? This green space is used by the community every day, even in winter.
- Can the design preserve usable, welcoming, community-oriented open space for all neighbors?
- Building size and massing
- What will the new building’s bulk, height, placement, and wall length mean for surrounding homes and streets? A three-story building will bring a big change in neighborhood impact.
- If the back side of a large gymnasium faces homes that currently face open green space, as is indicated by some of the plans, what will neighbors actually experience?
- Please provide sightline studies showing views from the street, sidewalk, front porches, and front windows for current residents.
- Please consider setbacks, landscaping, and community-facing design elements that reduce negative impacts.
- Traffic, drop-off, and circulation
- What should neighbors expect during peak morning arrival and afternoon dismissal?
- How many buses and how many private vehicles are projected?
- Will nearby residential streets absorb overflow traffic, queuing, or event parking?
- What are the effects on pedestrian safety, emergency access, winter conditions, and after-hours gym use?
- Please provide a full traffic study that answers these questions; the proposed school has a capacity of nearly 700 students, this is far larger than the number of students who were served by Cooper School
- Long-term viability
- How will MPS ensure that the site remains educationally and financially sustainable over time?
- Current MPS guidance indicates a recommended minimum enrollment for a K–8 school of roughly 1,018–1,133 students.
- The current Concept 1B capacity of 650–700 students appears out of step with that guidance.
- What are the enrollment assumptions, and what happens if sufficient enrollment growth does not materialize? There is neighborhood concern that we will be trading a cherished community space for a building that will fall into disuse if enrollment fails to grow.
- How will MPS manage the long-term costs of maintaining this major capital investment? Even if money materializes for construction, how will operations be supported over time? What if they can’t be?
My request to the board: please do not advance the project further without a transparent public review of the site plan, including green-space preservation and community access, building massing and sightline impacts, traffic and circulation, and long-term viability. I support the school. I want a better site plan and transparent process that involves the public.
A good and fair outcome should support Anishinabe Academy students while also fully informing and serving the needs of the surrounding neighborhood.
Respectfully,
J. Reed, neighbor to the former Cooper Elementary site
3200 block of 44th Avenue South
boesger73
https://www.change.org/savecooperpark
Monday, June 22 Report this